By Eric A. Shore, Founding Attorney
Eric A. Shore has been an injury and disability lawyer for more than 30 years.
Last updated: October 2026 Reading time: About 4 minutes
Quick Answer
If you were hurt in a New Jersey highway pileup, more than one driver may be responsible. One driver may have caused the first crash. Another may have been following too closely or speeding. New Jersey law lets the blame be split among all of them, and a driver found 60% or more at fault may be required to pay the full amount of your recoverable damages.
Why Is Fault So Hard to Figure Out in a Pileup?
Multi-car accidents are some of the most interesting cases I handle. They are interesting for the same reason they are hard. It is often not clear who caused the crash.
Did someone slam on the brakes? Was another driver speeding? Did someone change lanes without looking? Sometimes all three happen within a few seconds of each other.
Here is an example. A driver brakes hard on the New Jersey Turnpike. The car behind stops in time, but the next car does not. That impact pushes the middle car into the next lane, where a truck hits it. If you were in that middle car, who caused your injuries? It could be the driver who braked, the driver who failed to stop, the truck driver, or more than one of them.
Braking hard is not automatically careless. The real question is whether each driver acted unreasonably and whether that helped cause the crash or your injuries. That is why you cannot figure out fault just by looking at which car hit which.
Can More Than One Driver Be Responsible?
Yes. In New Jersey, a jury or judge can give each driver a percentage of the blame. For example, one driver might be found 70% at fault and another 30% at fault. This is called comparative negligence.
Your own driving can count too. Under N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1, you can usually still get compensation if your negligence was not greater than the combined negligence of the defendants. In plain terms, you were not more at fault than the other drivers put together. Your award is then reduced by your share of the blame. That is why it matters so much to show exactly what each driver did.
What Is New Jersey’s 60% Rule?
Under N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.3, a driver found 60% or more at fault may be required to pay the full amount of your damages. A driver found less than 60% at fault usually pays only their own share.
Here is a simple example, assuming both drivers are legally responsible for the same injury. You were hurt in a three-car crash and you did nothing wrong. One driver is found 70% at fault. The other is found 30% at fault. Your damages are $100,000. The 70% driver may be required to pay the full $100,000. The 30% driver usually owes only $30,000.
You cannot collect the same money twice. But this rule matters when one driver has little insurance or cannot pay. It is one more reason to find every driver who shares the blame.
How Do You Prove Which Driver Caused Each Impact?
In a pileup, the first crash is not always the one that hurt you. You might be stopped in traffic when a car hits you from behind. Seconds later, another car hits that car and pushes it into you again. Each impact may need to be looked at on its own.
Evidence that can help includes:
- Dashcam and surveillance video
- Damage patterns on each vehicle
- Witness statements
- Police photos
- Skid marks and debris on the road
- Vehicle “black box” data
- Electronic records from commercial trucks
- Driver phone records, when they can legally be obtained
Many cars have an Event Data Recorder, often called a black box. Depending on the car, it may show speed, braking, and gas pedal use in the seconds before a crash. It can sometimes show whether a driver braked or how many impacts happened. But the data never tells the whole story. It has to be matched up with the vehicle damage, the witnesses, the road conditions, and the order of the impacts.
What If a Truck Was Involved?
When a tractor trailer or other commercial vehicle is involved, there is often more evidence. That can include truck dashcam video, electronic driving logs, maintenance records, and dispatch records.
The trucking company may also share the blame. That depends on who employed the driver, the condition of the truck, and what happened. But a truck is not at fault just because it was there. The evidence still has to show how the driver, the company, or the truck helped cause your injuries.
What Should You Do After a Highway Pileup?
Get safe and get medical care first. Once you are safe, these steps can help protect your claim:
- Report the accident. Make sure police write up the crash and list every vehicle involved.
- Photograph all the damage. Get every damaged area, even if it looks minor.
- Get witness names and phone numbers. Other drivers may have seen impacts you did not.
- Save any dashcam video. Keep the original and make a backup copy.
- Do not guess about what happened. If you do not know which car hit you first, say so.
- Hold off on repairs after a serious crash, if you can. The damage and the black box data may be important evidence.
Evidence disappears fast. Video gets recorded over, cars get repaired, and witnesses become hard to find.
What If Every Insurance Company Blames Someone Else?
This is one of the most frustrating parts of a pileup case. One insurance company blames the driver who was in the first crash. Another blames the driver who hit you. A third says the weather or traffic made the crash unavoidable. Each one has a different story, and none of them is automatically right.
In more than 30 years of handling injury cases, I have learned that a confusing crash gets clearer when you look at each impact separately instead of treating the pileup as one event.
Who was moving? Who was stopped? Who had time to react? Was a car already disabled when someone else hit it? Most of all, what does the evidence actually show?
The Bottom Line
If you were hurt in a New Jersey highway pileup, more than one driver may share the blame. New Jersey lets fault be split among drivers, and a driver found 60% or more at fault may be required to pay the full amount of your damages. Figuring out who caused a pileup is rarely as simple as finding the first car that crashed. Every impact matters, and so does the evidence showing what happened before it.
If you were seriously hurt in a multi-car accident in New Jersey, the Law Offices of Eric A. Shore can look at what happened, gather the evidence, and explain your options. Call
1-800-CANT-WORK for a free consultation.
This article provides general legal information and is not legal advice. Fault, insurance coverage, and compensation depend on the facts of each case and New Jersey law.





